Main content

10 most shocking moments in recent chart history

As the show moves to Fridays on Radio 1, here's a countdown of the anomalies and controversies that have defined the Top 40 in the last 10 years

To bring it into line with changes in the global release schedule, Radio 1’s Official Chart show has moved to Fridays. Greg James, above, will present the countdown as part of his regular show and if all this sounds dramatic, it might help to know that the charts have always been dramatic - none more so than in the last decade, during which time the music industry has changed beyond recognition. Here, then, is a Top 10 of recent shocking moments…

10. 50 Cent refuses to retire after Kanye beats him to No.1

There have countless epic battles for the top of the charts over the years, going all the way back to beating in 1967 and v. in 1995, which . In 2007, rap big guns and went head-to-head when they released their second and third albums respectively (Curtis and Graduation) on the same day. 50 Cent said he'd retire if he lost. He did lose, badly, but carried on making music regardless.

9. Chris Moyles campaign gives Billie Piper an unexpected (repeat) hit song

In 2006, 's Crazy became the first song to top the charts on download sales alone, but it was also released physically, as charts rules dictated it needed to be. That rule was overturned in 2007, leading to a Chris Moyles experiment: if enough people bought an old song, Honey to the Bee - a number 3 hit eight years previously - could it chart again even if it wasn't being re-released as a single? He cheekily promoted the song on his Radio 1 show and it worked: the following week it reappeared in the chart at number 17.

8. First official vinyl album chart launches - in 2015!

Noel Gallagher sings If I Had a Gun

Noel Gallagher performs If I Had a Gun from his album Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds.

Who could possibly have imagined this? Vinyl as a format seemed dead after the CD was introduced, but it's made something of a comeback in recent years. It still accounts for a fraction of all music sales, but nonetheless more than a million vinyl records were sold in 2014 for the first time since 1996. Accordingly, the Official Charts Company have introduced a specific vinyl chart in 2015 for the first time. This year's top-seller so far? - in both the vinyl album and singles chart.

7. Greg James reads out a chart that's four-weeks old

Lots of things are going wrong today. I've got a confession to make..."
Greg James

D'oh! Poor old Greg. In 2012, when he was presenting the Official Chart Update, he read out the countdown from a month previous and played songs from the old chart, too. Realising his mistake, he said: "Lots of things are going wrong today. I've got a confession to make. The rundown which we did about five mins ago was in fact a rundown from four weeks ago." But he's not the only presenter with a chart blooper to his name - in 1993 Bruno Brookes accidentally played the uncensored version of 's Killing in the Name.

6. Spoof talent show contestant beats X Factor winner in chart battle

Oh, the irony: Peter Kay (most recently seen in ) creates a fictional character, Geraldine McQueen, to be the star of a 2008 TV show called - deep breath - Britain's Got the Pop Factor... and Possibly a New Celebrity Jesus Christ Soapstar Superstar Strictly on Ice, which was a parody of programmes like The X Factor. Then the spin-off single, , goes to number 2 in the charts, beating Don't Call This Love by reigning X Factor champion . A protest? Possibly, or maybe we just love a novelty song. Who remembers the ? Yup, Christmas No.1 in 1993.

5. YouTuber Alex Day becomes first unsigned artist to break the Top 5

Christmas Chart Update - Alex Day talks to Greg

Alex Day drops by the studio to find out who's in the lead in the race to become the year's Christmas No 1.

It's just my first song, and it just happens to have taken off now"
Alex Day

This took everyone by surprise - everyone, that is, who had never paid attention to the world of YouTubers. And what's even more remarkable about musician/vlogger 's self-released single Forever Yours reaching number 4 in 2011 was that it did so in the Christmas chart, selling more than 50,000 copies and beating the likes of and . "It's just my first song, and it just happens to have taken off now," Alex told Greg, but there was a cleverly organised campaign behind it. The following week Forever Yours broke another record - for falling 108 places in the chart, the biggest drop ever.

4. 2012 becomes the biggest year for singles sales in history

Gotye is number 1 in the Official Chart

Reggie chats to Gotye about his huge hit - Somebody That I Used To Know

Doomsayers said the ease of downloading illegally would kill music, just as home taping was identified as a threat in the 1980s. Albums have suffered terribly, but singles sales boomed in the downloading era - to 188.6m in 2012, the highest ever. But then we all started streaming, with the result that the 2012 peak in sales - topped by 's Somebody That I Used to Know - is unlikely to be beaten.

3. Ed Sheeran’s Thinking Out Loud breaks three landmark records

Ed Sheeran's Thinking Out Loud is Number 1

Ed Sheeran speaks to Scott about Thinking Out Loud reaching Number 1.

I didn't expect it to hang around that long"
Ed Sheeran

As Scott Mills tells here, Thinking Out Loud had the longest ascent to No.1 in chart history, and it's broken other records since. It's the first single to have reached the top spot as a direct result of streaming inclusion (introduced last year), and it's now the first song ever to have spent an entire year in the Top 40. And somewhere within those records are clues to how the charts will look from now on as they become defined by streaming figures, not old-fashioned sales.

2. Anti-Thatcher song, Ding-Dong! The Witch is Dead, enters chart at number 2

A controversial No. 2 in the Official Chart

Radio 1's Newsbeat explains the curious rise of a 73-year-old song to No. 2.

This song, from the soundtrack to 1939 film The Wizard of Oz, shot up to number 2 in the charts in the wake of Margaret Thatcher's death in 2013. In doing so, it became engulfed in a storm of controversy, not least at the Â鶹ԼÅÄ. Rather than playing the song in full during the Official Chart show, a Newsbeat report was aired (above). Radio 1 Controller Ben Cooper also explained his decision on 5 live.

1. Rage Against the Machine beat Joe McElderry to Christmas No.1

Top spot goes to the grassroots protest against The X Factor and its then-dominance of the Christmas chart. There have been many such protests since, but none as successful as getting 's Killing In the Name to Christmas No.1 in 2009 in place of 's winner's song, The Climb. It was a genuinely shocking chart moment. Then RATM were invited onto 5 live to perform the song, and all hell broke loose again.