The Thetis disaster
The North Wales coast has seen many shipping disasters over the years but none more tragic than the loss of the brand new submarine HMS "Thetis" in the summer of 1939. The submarine was on her maiden voyage and 99 men died when she sank in the waters of Liverpool Bay, just 15 miles to the east of Llandudno.
Launched on 1 June 1939 from the Cammel Laird Shipyards in Birkenhead, she left for her trials/maiden voyage on the 31st of the month.
On board were 103 men, more than twice her intended complement. Just 69 were sailors, the rest being dockyard officials, engineers and technicians. It was very cramped inside that fragile hull.
The plan was for the "Thetis" to make her first dive during the trip and the civilians on board were offered the chance to leave the boat - submarines, for some reason, are always called boat, rather than ship - before the dive. All of them chose to remain on board.
The first dive attempt failed as, it was felt, the boat was too light and the decision was taken to add seawater to the torpedo tubes to make her heavier. Unbeknown to anyone the outer torpedo tube doors were already open and, therefore, the tubes were already full of water - during the painting process some weeks earlier enamel had dripped and solidified on the test tap that would and should have told Lt Frederick Woods that the doors were already open. Woods, like the rest of the men onboard, believed the tubes were empty.
The moment they began to flood the torpedo tubes, hundreds of tonnes of seawater quickly flooded into the forward compartments and the "Thetis" simply nose dived to the bottom.
It was three hours before help arrived and by that stage, the crew had already pumped out 60 tonnes of drinking water and fuel oil in an attempt to lighten her and bring her to the surface but the submarine was lying bow down with her stern protruding out of the water.
It seemed, for a while, that there was a good chance of getting the men out but vital cutting equipment arrived too late and those rescue vessels that quickly sped to the scene were literally helpless to do anything.
For 13 hours she lay, stern free of the sea with the trapped men almost within touching distance. Inside the metal hull air was running out as carbon dioxide slowly began to flood through the decks.
Lt Woods and three other sailors managed to escape using the Davis Escape gear that all submarines carried. They had squeezed through a small hatch and out into the murky water. However, when four other men tried the same route they were drowned and the escape attempts were abandoned.
A salvage ship had now appeared on the scene and a wire hawser was looped around the stern of the submarine, in an attempt to keep it raised. But with the rising tide the hawser snapped and at 3pm on 1 July the "Thetis" slipped below the surface. She did not reappear.
Rescuers were now helpless and, inevitably, the men on board became sleepier and sleepier before death finally closed in. In all, 99 men died in the tragedy. The subsequent Court of Inquiry decided that no blame could be attached to any individual and there the matter was dropped.
Shortly after the disaster war was declared on Germany and the Admiralty knew that it would soon require all the submarines it could get. As a consequence, the "Thetis" was raised from the seabed with the bodies of the sailors and dockyard workers still inside. She was beached at Traeth Bychan near Moelfre so that the men could be removed and initial investigation work carried out. Then the unlucky boat was taken back to the dockyard for repairs and modification.
The unlucky tag stuck, however. Renamed "Thunderer" she went to the Mediterranean for operations against the Italians. There, in March 1943, she was sunk in action off Sicily. This time they did not raise her again.
Comment number 1.
At 20th Jun 2011, rmacmhor wrote:There has been speculation that the Admiralty βtook their eyes off the ballβ during the salvage of HMS Thetis. So keen were they to recover the submarine with WW2 looming, that they miscalculated the time that the crew could survive entombed in the stricken vessel.
The early 1950s saw two disasters with Royal Navy submarines. HMS Truculent, another T boat was proceeding down the Thames from Chatham in darkness in January 1950 and was involved in collision with an oil tanker. Many of the crew escaped the submarine and some were picked up but many perished in the cold waters of the Thames. A relative was a βdockyard mateyβ in Sheerness Dockyard at the time and told me there was a real feeling of gloom in the Yard when Truculent was eventually brought in. They didnβt refit her, she was sold off for scrap.
Another relative, working in Portsmouth Dockyard told me how he watched the ill-fated HMS Affray leave the Yard in 1951 as she went off on a training exercise and then vanished. It took a couple of months to find her, lying in nearly 300 feet of water on the edge of the Hurd Deep, she had sunk with all hands. The most likely explanation for her sinking seems to be a snapped βsnortβ mast. This probably remains the worst post war disaster involving a Royal Navy submarine.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 1)
Comment number 2.
At 20th Jun 2011, Phil wrote:Like you say, Roger, there were so many submarine disasters in the early days - probably because the technology was so new and much of what went on was by trial and error. One near-disaster took place just off St Anne's Head in 1918, involving the submarine L10, built at Pembroke Dockyard. She was engaged in diving trials and failed to surface after touching the bottom. Several dockyard men were on board for the trials but luckily for everyone on board the fault was located and, after several hours, the L10 surfaced once more. It could have been a lot worse and I suppose there are many such stories about early submarines. L10, incidentally, was sunk a few months later, depth charged by a German destroyer.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 2)