An offer that Sainsbury can refuse
Not long now till we learn whether that for .
Theyβve been mulling long enough for J Sainsburyβs board to think about forcing their hand. It can do that by going to the Takeover Panel to request that the putative bidders βput up or shut upβ, to use the City clichΓ©.
But the quartet will probably pre-empt that mild humiliation.
The stakes have been raised by the recent noisy debate about whether private equity is a good or bad thing.
The GMBβs attack on private equity has increased the reputational risks for CVC, TPG, Blackstone and KKR, the private-equity four, of engaging in a long and protracted public process (and the key word is βpublicβ) of trying to buy such a well-known retailing name with so many employees. That probably reduces the price they would be prepared to pay.
However the tilt at Sainsbury has taken on a significance even beyond the bald fact that it would be the UKβs biggest private-equity takeover.
It would be highly damaging for private equityβs long-term ability to invest its billions in the UK, if the quartet didnβt bid at all and allowed their trade-union critics to claim victory. The boards of public companies would question whether they really had the bottle for deals when the going gets tough and would be less minded to negotiate with them.
So hereβs my prediction: the four will make a conditional bid, pitched at a level just below what the board of J Sainsbury would feel obliged to accept.
It will be an almost-serious bid, or one that protects private equity from the charge that it is running away with its tails between its legs.
In terms of price, that would put a conditional offer at nearer Β£5 per share than Β£6: not derisory, but not quite high enough to allow the quartet to feast on Sainsbury.
The honour (if thatβs the right word) of private equity will however have been preserved. And another mega private-equity bid of another famous British business will come along before too long.
As an addendum, Permira looks to me to be the clever-clogs in this soap opera, having contemplated but resisted the urge to turn the Sainsbury private-equity quartet into a quintet.
Update 15:30 GMT: The has today ordered the private equity quartet to bid by April 13. Which is long enough for an almost-serious offer to be made and then politely rejected.
I'm 
°δ΄Η³Ύ³Ύ±π²Τ³Ω²υΜύΜύ Post your comment
The real bid for Sainsbury is more likely to come from M&S with Stuart Rose to become Chairman and Justin King as CEO of the combined group.
Sainsbury are lagging behind Tesco in their non food offering and M&S can bring some skills in that area.
I doubt M&S will as Stuart Rose was forced hours after speculating in a speech made last week decribing the pairing "interesting" to concede that they were not going to consider a bid, hence ruling them out for 6 months by which time the dust will have settled.
i work for sainsburys - and have shares in the company. I would love to see a merged JS and M+S, it would be a real force on the high street - with M+S being able to extend its food range, without compromising its long term policies - and JS would get a larger non-food, primerally clothing market. TU in sainsburys would compliment M+S brands well, as offers somthing similar in style but different in price.