Main content

Extrapolation

How reliable is extrapolation to accurately forecast the future or to understand the past?

Extrapolation in mathematics means extending the implications of a model beyond the range in which it was derived. In other words, using what we know to make educated guesses about what we don’t. But does extrapolation works so well when applied to the real world? Can mathematical models really indicate when the next ice age might come? Does genetic testing reliably tell us who our ancestors were? And when we sieve through fragments of history, can we ever escape the assumptions which colour what we will think? Joining Bridget Kendall to explore extrapolation are anthropologist Kim Tallbear who is a member of the Sisseton Wahpeton Oyate from South Dakota in the US; Ian Stewart emeritus professor of Mathematics at Warwick University in the UK and Joan Breton Connelly, classical archaeologist and professor of Classics and Art History at New York University in the US.

Image: Woolly Mammoth by Roger Harris/ Science Photo Library)

Available now

41 minutes

Last on

Mon 19 May 2014 02:06GMT

Chapters

  • Mathematician Ian Stewart

    Extrapolation in mathematics and in science-fiction

    Duration: 13:03

  • Anthropologist Kim Tallbear

    How DNA testing is changing the way Native Americans think about tribal membership

    Duration: 09:57

  • 60 Second Idea

    World-wide legislation to stamp out Maths abuse

    Duration: 05:05

  • Classical archaeologist and art historian Joan Breton Connelly

    The enigmatic Parthenon building in Athens, Greece

    Duration: 12:25

Ian Stewart

Ian Stewart

Ian Stewart is Emeritus Professor of Maths at Warwick University, with a dual career as a research mathematician and as a populariser of mathematics, communicating ideas of numbers and mathematics to the general public.  He has written more than 35 popular science books, contributed to the hugely successful comic fantasy DiscWorld novels by Terry Pratchett as well as writing short stories and novels of science fiction.  His latest project, the iPad app Incredible Numbers, has just appeared.  He argues that extrapolation in mathematics means extending the implications of a model or theory beyond the range in which it was derived. This procedure can be exciting and informative, or naive and silly—and it's not always easy to tell which is which.

Kim Tallbear

Kim Tallbear

Kim Tallbear – Associate Professor of Anthropology, University of Texas. She is a member of the Sisseton Wahpeton Oyate, part of the Santee Dakota people in South Dakota and  author of Native American DNA: Tribal belonging and the false promise of genetic science (University of Minnesota Press).  She is interested in looking at the way that DNA testing is changing how Native Americans think about tribal membership.  She argues that genetic science is a blunt tool to try and understand identity because it is not just  a matter of  blood -ties. 

Joan Breton Connelly

Joan Breton Connelly

Joan Breton Connelly – American classical archaeologist and Professor of Classics and Art History at New York University. She is Director of the Yeronisos Island Excavations and Field School in Cyprus and author of The Parthenon Enigma.  Controversially she argues that  modern preoccupations with beauty, proportion and secular ideas of democracy have  been projected back into the past which have lead to a misunderstanding of  the Parthenon of Athens.  Far from being an icon of Western secular civilisation it is a monument which glorifies self-sacrifice for the common good , set in a world of cult ritual.  

60 Second Idea to Change the World

60 Second Idea to Change the World
Ian Stewart wants to stamp out maths abuse.  There are two main kinds: using bad mathematics to mislead or confuse, and airbrushing maths out of history when it plays a vital role but does not get mentioned. He wants worldwide legislation forcing all such cases to display a bright red MATHS ABUSE sticker. Audio abuses should be preceded by a suitably rude noise. It’s a novel way to improve the public perception of mathematics and convince doubters that it’s important.

Broadcasts

  • Sat 17 May 2014 21:06GMT
  • Sun 18 May 2014 09:06GMT
  • Mon 19 May 2014 02:06GMT

Do you think political or business leaders need to be charismatic? Or do you prefer highly competent but somewhat stern people?

Do you think political or business leaders need to be charismatic? Or do you prefer highly competent but somewhat stern people?

We’d love to hear your views on charm and charisma for a future Forum.

Podcast