Main content
Sorry, this episode is not currently available

The Good Old Days

Ethical and religious discussion examining some of the larger questions of life. John McCarthy gazes back fondly and argues that nostalgia has a lot to offer us.

John McCarthy looks back over the history of nostalgia, tracing the term back to the 17th century when a medical student coined it as a way of describing the bouts of homesickness the Swiss mercenaries were experiencing while fighting far from their native mountains.

In years past, treatment for nostalgia ranged from the application of leeches to being buried alive.

For John, far from being a disease, nostalgia is something that can be harnessed with beneficial results. Reflecting on his own time as a hostage in Lebanon, John explains that nostalgia can strengthen us, as long as it doesn't develop into a morbid obsession.

While homesickness and nostalgia might have plagued soldiers, they have always provided artists and composers with a powerful source of inspiration. Featured music includes Antonín Dvorák's Symphony Number 9 - From The New World, George Butterworth's setting of The Lads in their Hundreds and Robert Schumann's Kinderszenen. Poetry includes the work of John Masefield and Carol Ann Duffy.

John discovers that there is much to be gained from examining nostalgia through the lens of religion. The sermons of C S Lewis, the words of the Buddha and the research of Friar Dr Paul Witts who has studied the role of nostalgia in the life of the local church, all provide fertile material for contemplation. John also draws upon the works of Sigmund Freud and the 18th century British regimental surgeon Robert Hamilton.

John concludes that, while nostalgia certainly has a lot to offer, we shouldn't let it trump an enjoyment of the here now. After all, as the American band Eels so poignantly declare, these could be the good old days.

Presenter: John McCarthy
Producer: Max O'Brien
A TBI Media production for Â鶹ԼÅÄ Radio 4.

30 minutes

Last on

Sun 2 Oct 2016 23:30

Music Played

  • Iain Burnside & Roderick Williams

    The Lads In Their Hundreds

  • London Philharmonic Orchestra

    Antonin Dvorak’s Symphony No 9 in E Minor op 95 - From The New World

  • Bryn Terfel

    Going Â鶹ԼÅÄ

  • Radu Lupu

    Robert Schumann’s Kinderszenen op 15 VII. Träumerei

  • EELS

    The Good Old Days

Readings

Title: Nostalgia

Author: Carol Ann Duffy

Publisher: Picador

Ìý

Title: History of a Remarkable Case of Nostalgia Affecting a Native of Wales and Occurring in Britain

Author: Robert Hamilton

Publisher: Andrew Duncan

Ìý

Title: The Complete Works of Sigmund FreudÌýVolume 3

Author: Sigmund Freud

Publisher: ÌýThe Hogarth Press

Ìý

Title: The Weight of Glory

Author: CS Lewis

Publisher: SPCK

Ìý

Title: ÌýThe Majjhima Nikaya

Author: Thanissaro Bhikku (translator)

Publisher: Access to Insight

Ìý

Title: Wabi Sabi Simple

Author: Richard R Powell

Publisher: Adams Media

Ìý

Title: Perspectives on Nostalgia

Author: Fr Dr Paul Witts

Publisher: NA

Ìý

Title: Sea Fever

Author: John Masefield

Publisher: Grant Richards

Ìý

Broadcasts

  • Sun 2 Oct 2016 06:05
  • Sun 2 Oct 2016 23:30