Main content

The Arguments Against Democracy

Rana Mitter and guests discuss the arguments against democracy. With Professor David Runciman, Duncan Kelly, Patricia Thornton and Tim Stanley.

Rana Mitter and guests discuss the arguments against democracy.

Churchill famously commented that 'democracy is the worst form of government, except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time'. Yet China has grown to be the world's second biggest economy under a non-democratic system, and until just a few decades ago, even the liberal west put heavy restrictions on who could vote. Plato opposed it, and his arguments begin a long tradition of principled objection to the idea of rule by the people, advanced by philosophers like Friedrich Nietzsche and Carl Schmitt.

Do thinkers like these make a case that could prompt us to return to first principles and rethink whether democracy really works? And should democracy be able to find space in the public sphere for those who argue against it? We test Free Thinking to its limits by looking at the alternatives to our own political system.

Available now

45 minutes

Credits

Role Contributor
Presenter Rana Mitter
Interviewed Guest David Runciman
Interviewed Guest Duncan Kelly
Interviewed Guest Patricia Thornton
Interviewed Guest Tim Stanley
Producer Luke Mulhall

Broadcast

  • Wed 4 Mar 2015 22:00

Featured in...

The Arts & Ideas Podcast

The Arts & Ideas Podcast

You can download all the past episodes of Radio 3's Free Thinking

Discussions and talks from the Free Thinking Festival 2019

Discussions and talks from the Free Thinking Festival 2019

Angry politics, what we can’t say, being diplomatic, weeping, emotion in music, film & TV

Click to listen to discussions, talks and music as the Free Thinking Festival 2019 Gets Emotional

Click to listen to discussions, talks and music as the Free Thinking Festival 2019 Gets Emotional

Angry politics, what we can’t say, being diplomatic, weeping, emotion in music, film & TV

CLICK to LISTEN & SEE programmes from the Free Thinking Festival 2018: The One & the Many

CLICK to LISTEN & SEE programmes from the Free Thinking Festival 2018: The One & the Many

We examine the fast-changing relationship between the individual & the crowd

CLICK to LISTEN & SEE all programmes, images, clips & features from 2017's festival

Free Thinking Festival 2017: The Speed of Life