This discussion has been closed.
Posted by Ankhesenamun15 (U2550768) on Tuesday, 22nd November 2005
Hey i'm not asking a question just wanna see if any ppl actually wanna chat about Egypt rather than just answering questions.
Ankhesenamun x
, in reply to message 1.
Posted by goodoldphilusa (U2519971) on Tuesday, 22nd November 2005
I might. 'sup?
goodoldphil
Maybe. Start something off, and I'll join in.....as long as it's not too technical.
, in reply to message 1.
Posted by nefretari_2005 (U2576173) on Wednesday, 23rd November 2005
hi ankhesenamun15,i would love to chat to you about egypt,coz i really love it and cant wait to go back there from nefretari_2005
hmmm... good conversation pieces, ummm... How many egyptian gods were there?
bast, seth, ptah, osiris, ra, aten, anubis, thoth, umm, that dwarf guy, isis? 10, i can name
If you want my opinion I think that all the pharohes age were the interested time of egypt
If you want my opinion I think that all the pharohes age were the interested time of egypt
hmmm... good conversation pieces, ummm... How many egyptian gods were there?
bast, seth, ptah, osiris, ra, aten, anubis, thoth, umm, that dwarf guy, isis? 10, i can nameΒ
, in reply to message 5.
Posted by Ankhesenamun15 (U2550768) on Thursday, 24th November 2005
hey hallamhal, just to answer your question, there are hundreds, representing every aspect of ancient Egyptian life. The dwarf guys name was Bes by the way lol.
Hey Nefertari what shall we chat bout then?
Ankhesenamun xxx
, in reply to message 5.
Posted by Β§ilver ghΓΈst (U2315521) on Saturday, 26th November 2005
hmmm... good conversation pieces, ummm... How many egyptian gods were there?
bast, seth, ptah, osiris, ra, aten, anubis, thoth, umm, that dwarf guy, isis? 10, i can nameΒ
Bast
seth
ptah
Re
Aten
anubis
thoth
Bes
isis
Khumn
hathor
wadjet
geb
maat
tawret
sheshat
sokar
neith
amun
sekhmet
horus
kepry
shut and tefnut
nut
bastet
selquet
khonsu
montu
nephthys
wepwawet
ammut
apophis
hapy
sarapis (thougth this god was "invented" by Alexander the great afer he conquered Egypt.)
Thats all I can think of
Now that we've got on to the subject of the huge amount of deities that existed for all aspects of everyday life and death, maybe we should consider the impact of Akhenaten (Amenophis IV?) and his insistence that the one true God was the sun, the Aten. After all, the Sun gives life to everyone, and every living thing, doesn't it? Perhaps he was right, but what kind of impact would it have after generations of polytheism to be suddenly told you are wrong. There is only one God above all others, and it is a previously relatively minor God. Is it any surprise that after his death the whole thing collapsed in disarray and shame?? Did Tutankhamen (Nebkhprure) go back to the old ways purely to protect his throne, or was he astute enough to realise there may have been some truth in the teachings of Akhenaten?? What we are seeing is the birth of religion in the form which we recognise today. Akhenaten's teachings even show through in modern Christianity. Was this man too far ahead of his time and ultimately doomed, misunderstood?? Akhenaten began to believe he was the son of the Aten, God, what are the comparisons of Akhenaten and the man we call Jesus Christ??
It is possible that Akhenaten was the brother of Moses. It is known that Akhenaten was the second son of Amenhotep III and the fate of his elder son ThutMOSIS is unknown. If he was Moses it could explain why Amenhotep III had made so many statues of Sekhmet the lion-headed godess slayer of mankind as an appeasement for the plagues and death of the firstborn and Akhenaten's adoption of a monotheistic religion.
ATB Mike.
Mike
The idea that Tuthmosis being the biblical Moses has recently been gone into great depth over on the Jewish Religion board and pretty well de-bunked as a theory
, in reply to message 12.
Posted by Ankhesenamun15 (U2550768) on Monday, 28th November 2005
Hello, it is impossible that Akenatens brother was the biblical Moses because Moses was in Egypt i think around Rameses II reign if i remember correctly. Also "Did Tutankhamen (Nebkhprure) go back to the old ways purely to protect his throne, or was he astute enough to realise there may have been some truth in the teachings of Akhenaten??" To answer that Tutankhamun may have restored the Gods to respects the people of Egypt, but he did not abolish the Aten which can still be seen in some of his objects. All it meant was the Aten became a regular diety rather than a head God. Tutankhamun was brought up in Aketaten so he lived by the way of the Aten. The change was mostly done by his uncle Ay, the general Horemheb and the treasurer Maya. Plus Tutankhamun remained in Aketaten until he was twelve whilst his advisors restored faith. Tutankhamun most certainly did not hate the old regime!
Ankhesenamun xx
, in reply to message 13.
Posted by Crystal Clear (U1010754) on Monday, 28th November 2005
For an idea on how much Tutenkhamun followed his father's religion, look at his name. He changed it back after Akhenaten died to be associated with Amun once again. The Restoration Stele makes in pretty clear that Tut was dissasociated with Akhenaten. To what extent this was all his own work is debatable, after all he came to the throne when he was ten, its hard to imagine that he did all of this himself. Its likely that people wanted to reestablish the old order I mean, how would you feel if a new religion was suddenly imposed on you and you had to conform to it. Looking through the successive dynasties you can tell that the pharoahs were still reeling from Akhenaten's reign and suddenly art became more overtly religious, all the Gods were included. He has a huge impact but I think the majority wanted to forget he ever existed. His reforms were just a little bit too radical
, in reply to message 1.
Posted by nefernefruaten (U2973790) on Monday, 16th January 2006
hi id love to chat to you about egypt i can talk about it all day and never get tired maybe we can become penpals and discuss things about egypt.
, in reply to message 15.
Posted by Crystal Clear (U1010754) on Wednesday, 18th January 2006
Ok then. Anyone been to Egypt? Im going at the end of march and just wondering if its really that dangerous getting to Abu Simbel as we are going there
, in reply to message 16.
Posted by nefernefruaten (U2973790) on Saturday, 21st January 2006
hi i dont thinks its dangerouse going to Abu Simbel as i think there is a nile cruse you can go on and it will take you to all sites of interest ie. luxor temple the aswan dam , temple island of phlaie ect. id love to go make sure to take lots of pics !!!!!
i was in luxor last june on my honeymoon, went to the temples and the vally of kings it was fine but apart from that there,s nothing really to do outside your hotel
, in reply to message 10.
Posted by OldKingCole72 (U1815644) on Monday, 23rd January 2006
I see little parallel between Akhenaten's worship of the solar disc and Christianity except in the belief of one God. Religion was still the preserve of the elite in Akhetaten's Egypt - indeed it became even more exclusively the preserve of the the very highest class (the Pharoah and his family) to the detriment of the wider priesthood - whereas Christianity's teachings emphasise the importance of the wider population and of the lowest, poorest and weakest members of society. Akhetaten did not minister to his people or concern himself with their tribulations, but lived a life of incredible luxury and splendid isolation. In this he has much more in common with the traditional Egyptian religious system than anything else.
, in reply to message 19.
Posted by lazysharon (U3050001) on Wednesday, 25th January 2006
i have been to egypt and i watch a lot of it on tv,what do you want to chat about,as long as it is not difficult
tell us what you know then
Theres a few problems with your notion that Akhenaten CANT be Moses. Firstly you assume that all biblical material is literal and historically accurate. We know from a variety of sources that this isnt the case. Second you assume that if the biblical Moses and the author of the Torah are the same person. Although there are many arguments that the author of the Torah is the same person there's no reason scientifically to believe that this person is the actual Moses we've come to accept as a leader of the Israelites people. Lastly you assume that early Israelite culture and religion are in some way similar to Christianity when in fact by Jesus own admission he came to bring a new revision on old believes. Jesus' contribution to Judaism was to make compassion (Ma'at, Logos) from and center in the process of judging others and in ones own life.
Take away the biblical mythology (or fact if your a believer) for a second and look at the parallels and its quite possible that Akenhaton and his brother Tuthmosis are the biblical characters Aaron and Moses.
Modern Egypt or Ancient Egypt?
The History message boards are now closed. They remain visible as a matter of record but the opportunity to add new comments or open new threads is no longer available. Thank you all for your valued contributions over many years.
or Β to take part in a discussion.
The message board is currently closed for posting.
The message board is closed for posting.
This messageboard is .
Find out more about this board's
Βι¶ΉΤΌΕΔ Β© 2014 The Βι¶ΉΤΌΕΔ is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.
This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.